This one requires some logic, are you up to it:

Answer:
Ben Owns the Goldfish! (and the Dog!)
Explanation:
How to use the 5 indices too find the answer:
1.
| NAME | AMY | ||
| HOUSE | RED | ||
| PET | |||
2.
| NAME | AMY | ||
| HOUSE | RED | BLUE | |
| PET | TURTLE | ||
3.
| NAME | AMY | BEN | |
| HOUSE | RED | BLUE | |
| PET | TURTLE | DOG | |
4.
| NAME | AMY | CARA | BEN |
| HOUSE | RED | BLUE | YELLOW |
| PET | TURTLE | DOG | |
5.
| NAME | AMY | CARA | BEN |
| HOUSE | RED | BLUE | YELLOW |
| PET | TURTLE | DOG | |
| GOLDFISH |
Amy doesn’t have a pet and Ben has 2 pets!

